100% Mahi smoked on premise! Blended with capers, horseradish, bell pepper and red onion. Served with jalapeños – 13
100% Mahi smoked on premise! Blended with capers, horseradish, bell pepper and red onion. Served with jalapeños – 13
We listened to you!! Toasted English muffin topped with vine ripe tomato, homemade tuna salad and melted cheddar cheese – 14
Boar’s Head corned beef with Big Eye Swiss, sauerkraut, 1000 island dressing on grilled rye – 15 or sub grouper – 23
Prepared in your choice of blackened, broiled, fried or crunchy style. Topped with lettuce, red onion and vine ripe tomato – 17
Char-broiled to your liking, served up on a Kaiser bun with lettuce, red onion and vine-ripe tomato – 14.
Add cheese, sautéed mushrooms or bacon for 1.25 each.
Locally caught, fresh as can be – 16
Lean, slightly pink, moist and firm – 19
White, moist meat with a heavy flaky texture – 23
A classic recipe with clams, onion, celery, hickory smoked bacon, potatoes and heavy cream
Dave’s darn near perfect recipe, with a traditional tomato base and loaded with fresh conch, onion, celery, peppers and just the right spice. This is the soup we recommend!
A Message from Matanzas on the Bay
Our hearts are devastated by the loss of so many lives, homes and businesses in our community due to Hurricane Ian. Sadly, our beloved restaurant Matanzas on the Bay received extensive damage during the storm.
We are grateful for the outpouring of support, and we remain focused on helping our employees, neighbors and community as we get through this difficult time. We are assessing next steps for rebuilding the restaurant, yet we know it will likely be a long process.
If you’d like to support our staff, who are working to get back on their feet and facing unemployment while we rebuild, please consider contributing to our employee fundraiser at www.facebook.com/MatanzasInnResort.
If you have a gift card to our restaurant, please hold on to it and join us for a meal once we reopen or let us know if you’d like to donate the value to our staff for recovery. Unfortunately, our computer system was lost in the storm, so we are unable to provide refunds.
We thank you for your continued loyalty to Matanzas on the Bay over the past 30 years. Our team looks forward to serving you once again.